LEGAL SAFEGUARDS FOR ADMINISTRATIVE DECISIONS INVOLVING ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE IN PUBLIC SERVICES: INTERNATIONAL EXPERIENCE AND DIRECTIONS FOR IMPROVING UZBEKISTAN’S LEGISLATION

Authors

  • Ibragimova Shoxzoda Master’s Student, Tashkent State University of Law

Keywords:

artificial intelligence, public services, administrative document, administrative procedures, human oversight, reasoning of decisions, counterfactual explanation, administrative discretion, comparative legal analysis.

Abstract

The article analyses the system of legal safeguards for administrative decisions made with the participation of artificial intelligence in public service delivery, drawing on foreign experience and the legislation of Uzbekistan. The models of the European Union, Germany, France and Canada are compared against six criteria and set beside Article 7¹ of the Law “On Informatization” and the Law “On Administrative Procedures”. The study shows that the text of Article 7¹ prohibits reliance on conclusions produced “solely” with the use of artificial intelligence, which leaves open the risk of merely formal involvement of an official. At the same time, it argues that the existing provisions of the Law on Administrative Procedures (Articles 9, 15, 18, 33, 52–54 and 63–66) already imply a number of requirements for AI-assisted decisions. The author proposes a graded model of safeguards based on three roles of AI and on limiting full automation to bound decisions, criteria of meaningful human involvement, and a draft Article 52¹ (“Automated administrative document”).

References

Oʻzbekiston Respublikasi Prezidentining 2025-yil 11-iyuldagi PQ-425-son qarori “2025–2026-yillarda sunʼiy intellekt texnologiyalari sohasida ustuvor loyihalarni amalga oshirish chora-tadbirlari toʻgʻrisida”. URL: https://lex.uz/ru/pdfs/-7621993.

Oʻzbekiston Respublikasi Prezidentining 2025-yil 22-oktyabrdagi PF-189-son Farmoni “Sunʼiy intellekt texnologiyalarini yanada rivojlantirishga oid qoʻshimcha chora-tadbirlar toʻgʻrisida”. URL: https://lex.uz/en/docs/-7789403

Oʻzbekiston Respublikasining “Axborotlashtirish toʻgʻrisida”gi Qonuni, 2003-yil 11-dekabr, 560-II-son (2026-yil 21-yanvardagi OʻRQ-1115-son Qonun bilan kiritilgan oʻzgartirishlar, 3-, 7¹-moddalar bilan). URL: https://lex.uz/acts/-83472.

Sunʼiy intellektga asoslangan yechimlarni yaratish, joriy qilish va ulardan foydalanish boʻyicha etika qoidalari (Raqamli texnologiyalar vazirining 2026-yil 24-fevraldagi buyrugʻi bilan tasdiqlangan; Adliya vazirligida 2026-yil 14-martda 3787-son bilan roʻyxatdan oʻtgan). URL: https://lex.uz/uz/docs/8083233 .

Oʻzbekiston Respublikasi Prezidentining 2026-yil 24-iyuldagi PF-141-son Farmoni (raqamli texnologiyalar sohasida strategik rejalashtirish va davlat nazoratini takomillashtirish haqida). URL: https://gov.uz/oz/digital/news/view/198089

Oʻzbekiston Respublikasining “Maʼmuriy tartib-taomillar toʻgʻrisida”gi Qonuni, 2018-yil 8-yanvar, OʻRQ-457-son. URL: https://lex.uz/en/acts/-3492199.

Senatda “Maʼmuriy tartib-taomillar toʻgʻrisida”gi qonun rad etildi // OʻzA. – 2026. – 3-oktyabr. URL: https://uza.uz/oz/posts/senatda-mamuriy-tartib-taomillar-togrisidagi-qonun-rad-etildi_916657.

Citron D.K. Technological Due Process // Washington University Law Review. – 2008. – Vol. 85, No. 6. – P. 1249–1313.

Coglianese C., Lehr D. Regulating by Robot: Administrative Decision Making in the Machine-Learning Era // Georgetown Law Journal. – 2017. – Vol. 105. – P. 1147–1223.

Coglianese C., Lehr D. Transparency and Algorithmic Governance // Administrative Law Review. – 2019. – Vol. 71, No. 1. – P. 1–56.

Edwards L., Veale M. Slave to the Algorithm? Why a “Right to an Explanation” Is Probably Not the Remedy You Are Looking For // Duke Law & Technology Review. – 2017. – Vol. 16, No. 1. – P. 18–84.

Wachter S., Mittelstadt B., Russell C. Counterfactual Explanations without Opening the Black Box: Automated Decisions and the GDPR // Harvard Journal of Law & Technology. – 2018. – Vol. 31, No. 2. – P. 841–887.

Гулямов С.С., Рустамбеков И.Р., Нарзиев О.С., Худайберганов А.Ш. Проект Концепции Республики Узбекистан в области развития искусственного интеллекта на 2021–2030 годы // Yurisprudensiya. – 2021. – №1. – С. 106–120.

Regulation (EU) 2016/679 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 27 April 2016 (General Data Protection Regulation), Art. 22. URL: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2016/679/oj.

Regulation (EU) 2024/1689 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 13 June 2024 laying down harmonised rules on artificial intelligence (Artificial Intelligence Act), Annex III, Arts. 14, 26, 27, 86. URL: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2024/1689/oj

Court of Justice of the European Union. Judgment of 7 December 2023, Case C-634/21, OQ v Land Hessen (SCHUFA Holding (Scoring)), ECLI:EU:C:2023:957.

Verwaltungsverfahrensgesetz (VwVfG) [Maʼmuriy ish yuritish toʻgʻrisidagi qonun], §§ 24, 35a. – Berlin, 2017. URL: https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/vwvfg/

Code des relations entre le public et l’administration, art. L311-3-1 [Jamoatchilik va maʼmuriyat munosabatlari kodeksi]; Décret n° 2017-330 du 14 mars 2017, art. R311-3-1-1, R311-3-1-2. – Paris: Légifrance. URL: https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr .

Conseil constitutionnel. Décision n° 2018-765 DC du 12 juin 2018, Loi relative à la protection des données personnelles [Konstitutsiyaviy kengash qarori]. URL: https://www.conseil-constitutionnel.fr/decision/2018/2018765DC.htm

Treasury Board of Canada Secretariat. Directive on Automated Decision-Making [Avtomatlashtirilgan qaror qabul qilish toʻgʻrisidagi direktiva]. – Ottawa, 2019 (amended 2023). URL: https://www.tbs-sct.canada.ca/pol/doc-eng.aspx?id=32592 .

Downloads

Published

2026-11-17

How to Cite

Ibragimova Shoxzoda. (2026). LEGAL SAFEGUARDS FOR ADMINISTRATIVE DECISIONS INVOLVING ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE IN PUBLIC SERVICES: INTERNATIONAL EXPERIENCE AND DIRECTIONS FOR IMPROVING UZBEKISTAN’S LEGISLATION. SAMARALI TA’LIM VA BARQAROR INNOVATSIYALAR JURNALI, 4(11), 117–130. Retrieved from https://innovativepublication.uz/index.php/jelsi/article/view/6618